Thursday, December 3, 2020
Home INDIA India Coronavirus tests: Swabs don't damage the brain and other claims fact-checked

India Coronavirus tests: Swabs don’t damage the brain and other claims fact-checked

India

india A young man in a hoodie adminsters a swab test on himself

Image copyright
Al Seib

Claims that coronavirus tests can harm people are circulating on social media.

We investigated the claims in some of the most widely shared posts.

India The nose swab can’t damage the brain

A picture showing a swab test being taken has been circulated widely on Facebook and Instagram along with claims that the swab is taken at the “blood-brain barrier”.

The idea you could access the blood-brain barrier through a swab up the nose is a complete misunderstanding of what it is and how it works.

The brain has lots of layers of protection. First and mostly obviously is the skull and within that, the brain is further encased in a protective membrane and fluid.

Within the blood vessels that line the brain, the blood-brain barrier is a tightly packed layer of cells that stops molecules circulating in the blood from passing into the brain, while allowing in things like oxygen and nutrients.

A swab stick inserted into the nose would need to break through multiple layers of tissue and drill through a bone and into the blood vessels to reach the blood-brain barrier.

“The swab cannot reach the blood brain barrier without significant force that breaks several layers of tissue and bone. We have not seen any complications from Covid swabs in our neurology practice”, says Dr Liz Coulthard, a committee member of the British Neuroscience Association (BNA).

The nasopharyngeal swab checks for coronavirus in the back of the nasal passage and is one of a range of swabbing techniques.

A combined nose-and-throat swab is routinely used to test for Covid-19 in the UK.

“I have swabbed many patients while working in hospital and also do these swabs on myself every week as a volunteer in a trial. It is unusual to have something that far up your nose – the swab can feel itchy or tickly but it shouldn’t be painful,” says Dr Tom Wingfield of the Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine.

The false claims started to emerge in US-based Facebook accounts on 6 July and some versions include calls to refuse testing altogether.

Some of these have been rated “false” by fact-checking organisations on Facebook.

We’ve found the same graphic appearing in Romanian, French, Dutch and Portuguese posts, each generating thousands of engagements.

India Testing kits won’t infect you with coronavirus

Reports of contaminated test kits have been misinterpreted to imply that taking a test will give you coronavirus.

In fact, headlines shared about contamination refer to a report on ineffective tests caused by sloppy lab practices at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) early in the pandemic. This doesn’t mean that being tested will give you the virus.

In a post shared more than 3,000 times on Facebook this week, a fan page for Fox News host Tucker Carlson shared a news article about contaminated test kits saying: “You want Covid-19? This is how U get it!”

The full Washington Post article, which was published in June, details the findings of a federal review which found that faulty tests and lab procedures caused delays to the rollout of the CDC’s testing programme. It doesn’t suggest that faulty test kits could have passed on the virus to any patients.

The article is behind a pay wall, which means most people seeing posts sharing the article would read the headline out of context.

Fact checkers in the US and India have debunked wilder claims that the coronavirus test is a plot funded by the Gates Foundation to implant a microchip into patients. These false claims, shared thousands of times on Facebook, are similar to conspiracy theories we looked into previously about a sinister micro-chipping programme linked to a potential vaccine.

There is no evidence to suggest there is any micro-chipping programme linked to the coronavirus pandemic and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation has denied the claims.

India ‘Why can’t you just breathe on the swab?’

A meme asking, “If Covid was really carried on your breath, why can’t you just breathe on the swab? Why do they have to shove the swab to the very back of your nose?” has been engaged with at least 7,000 times on Facebook and Instagram.

Coronavirus spreads when an infected person coughs or sneezes small droplets – packed with the virus – into the air. This doesn’t mean that just breathing on a swab would collect enough material to conduct a laboratory test though.

We spoke to Public Health England about this who say taking a swab from inside the nose or throat yields more accurate test results.

If you only breathe on a slim swab head, you might not catch the viral particles or the cells that carry the virus. However, if you insert the swab in the nose and throat and rotate it at the site of infection, you are more likely to get infectious material that will yield a result.

India Faking virus-free certificates in Bangladesh

Finally, we’ve taken a look at the growing scandal in Bangladesh of faked certificates indicating a person does not have coronavirus.

Several people have been arrested there for issuing bogus documentation showing negative test results to people who haven’t actually been tested.

These documents have value because they are often required by migrant workers to show that they are virus-free when they arrive at their destination. Bangladesh relies heavily on income from its citizens working overseas.

In the latest incident, a hospital owner, accused of falsifying thousands of tests, was detained after a nine-day hunt near the Indian border, disguised as a woman.

Criminal gangs are also putting adverts on social media to find potential buyers.

Strangely, fake certificates indicating positive tests are also reported to be on sale in Bangladesh – offering up the chance for public servants to take leave from work.

Additional reporting by Olga Robinson and Shayan Sardarizadeh.

Read more from Reality Check

Send us your questions

Follow us on Twitter

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

India North Macedonia: Police discover 148 migrants in vans

Police in North Macedonia say they have discovered 148 migrants crammed into trucks in two separate operations in central and northern parts of the country, and have arrested two men on suspicion of trafficking migrantsAugust 12, 2020, 11:36 AM• 2 min readSKOPJE, North Macedonia -- Police in North Macedonia say they have discovered 148 migrants…

India Article 370: Curfew in Kashmir as protesters plan ‘black day

Publishedduration4 Augustimage copyrightGetty Imagesimage caption5 August is the first anniversary of the abrogation of Article 370Curfew has been imposed in Indian-administered Kashmir in anticipation of protests ahead of 5 August - the day the government stripped the region of its special status. Officials say the curfew is meant to prevent violence by groups planning to…

India The Newest: Confirmed coronavirus instances attain 20 million

BEIJING — China’s newly confirmed community transmitted cases of coronavirus fell into the single digits on Wednesday, while Hong Kong saw another 33 cases of infection.The National Health Commission said all nine new cases were found in the northwestern region of Xinjiang, whose capital Urumqi has been at the center of China’s latest major outbreak.…

India India’s financial system contracts by 24%, worst in at the least 24 years

India’s government says the country's economy contracted by 23.9% in the April-June quarter, its worst performance in at least 24 years, as the coronavirus pandemic ravaged what was once the world’s fastest growing major economyBy SHEIKH SAALIQ Associated PressAugust 31, 2020, 2:01 PM• 2 min readNEW DELHI -- India’s economy contracted by 23.9% in the…

Recent Comments